Talkback: Realis

Is supporting story the same as supporting genre?

the cover of realis, like an astronomical chart in brown and gold
Have we knowledge gained?
Listen to the latest episode in your podcast player of choice!

The second season of the Rascal Reading Club continues with the talkback to our previous episode about Realis, a game of psychedelic sword and sorcery by Austin Walker. I'm joined by co-hosts Sam Dunnewold and Kyle Tam to discuss your responses and how this game's mechanics and setting and genre feel intertwined together.

Excerpt

Nik's Response: It’s a beautifully-executed, enchanting game — both in the art and in the writing — but not one I ever see myself enjoying in play. I worry that the core implementation of Realization is too abstract: the game doesn’t provide a mechanical distinction between evolving the sentence “I always kill my foe” into “When my eyes are open, I always kill my foe” versus “When I’m standing in sand, I always kill my foe,” even though the latter feels like a more specific and therefore more radical act of self-realisation. The game does provide a fantastic palette of ideas though — I could easily imagine throwing in the acidic moon Caust or the glorious throne moon Baudekin into a sci-fi campaign in another system.
 Kyle: I guess what I want to say is that while the first sentence is technically something you could do I don't know if you've had this around your own tables. I know this is something that we have. The realization of sentences ends up becoming a group thing. You're not doing it by yourself. It ends up being for the attention of the class. What do we feel best suits not only the mechanical requirements of is this good for the party, but also does this suit the nature of the character?
Sam: This does not feel like a real thing to me. Because like, when my eyes are open, I always kill my foes suddenly says, "Oh, I understand. Your character has a religious order who must wear a blindfold all the time. Copy that." It feels like how you realize the sentence is gonna be so context-dependent. And if you're trying to win the role-playing game, like I don't know what you're doing here in the first place exactly.
Thomas: I think maybe I can frame this in a more productive way. When you talked about Fate aspects being difficult as well, I think there is this worry also that like what will happen automatically to you when you are playing is that you will want to make the sentences get stronger fictionally as well as mechanically, right? I think one of the cool things that Kyle mentioned, Nick, you're never going to realize a sentence in a way that feels fictionally irrelevant to everything that your character has done till this moment, There is a moment where you're gonna realize the sentence, but everyone's going to be like, "Oh, this fits because of that," and that's when you'll know that you made a good decision to some extent.
Sam: Can I therapize myself for a second? So I was talking before about this the feeling of playing the game feels like sort of carving out fictional positioning. It feels so much like a, a strategy fictional positioning game as a player. And I think that the reason writing sentences feels like high stakes to me is because this is the rare game that I feel like I want to play it in that sort of OSR fixed world, fixed setting kind of style. That the core activity of the game, of setting up all that fictional positioning is, I think, more fun in Realis with this set of mechanics when you have more legwork done in advance. When you have more things locked in advance. And I think that just suits Realis less well. you are bringing that sense of like, "I wanna fictionally position myself well. I do wanna strategize. I do wanna do that, that work." And yeah, to me that is gonna live in the play of the game more in the realization of the sentences when I think it will be easier to step out and let the character stuff go forward. Writing sentences feels so high stakes because I wanna lock that stuff in. I wanna play fair with the players, and have that stuff written in advance.
Thomas: Which also brings up this thing and I don't know if this is how it's worked for you, Kyle, as well, 'cause you talked about it being a table thing. When you write a sentence and you realize a sentence and you add a clause to it, like you and the GM have to be on the same page that what's gonna happen immediately after that is the GM throwing problems at you that don't fit that clause, You have to know that when you write, "When my eyes are open, I always kill my foe," that it is now the GM's job functionally. What you're communicating by the social compact of the game is, "Please blindfold me. Please put me in the dark. Please attack me when like I'm asleep."

Schedule

And as a reminder, here's the schedule for the rest of Season Two:

December - Stars without Number (Kevin Crawford)
January - Wildsea (Felix Isaacs)
February - Blades '68 (Tim Denee)