MTG Arena’s nascent union faces “optional” meetings, letters to homes, and management closing ranks
With a union vote looming, United Wizards of the Coast faces classic union busting from the tabletop industry’s largest company.
Members of the Magic: The Gathering Arena team currently unionizing told Rascal that parent company Wizards of the Coast (WotC) hijacked a May 28 town hall meeting as a platform for what two workers characterized as an hour of “union avoidant talking points”. This followed daily rounds of emails sent to all workers, along with letters mailed to their personal homes, as United Wizards of the Coast-CWA nears the start of a union voting period on Tuesday, June 2.
Speaking to Rascal on a call, producer Xib Vaine and senior software engineer Valentine Powell said a regularly scheduled all-hands digital meeting was co-opted by WotC management and pitched instead as a debate between those sympathetic to unionizing and those opposed. Powell said the opposition (read: management) dedicated the entire allotted hour to “diatribe at us with 30 union avoidant talking points” and filibustering, after stressing that, while optional, people would be missing critical information by not attending.
The meeting was another move that skirted technicalities regarding anti-union actions within the state of Washington, where captive audience meetings with the intent to discourage unionization were banned in 2024. Vaine and Powell, along with most other union supporters, did not stick around long enough to respond to this so-called debate, electing to get back to their jobs maintaining the digital video game version of MTG. “We’ve already got the numbers. There is no debate. We’re ready to unionize, so we didn’t feel the need to entertain them,” Powell said.
"I am organizing because I think it’s the best path forward for our team, and the games industry, to ensure that devs have a say in the decisions made about us."
— United Wizards of the Coast - CWA (@uwotc-official.bsky.social) May 23, 2026 at 10:02 PM
[image or embed]
Management’s language in the meeting reportedly mirrored the letters mailed to workers’ homes, which warned against the dangers of unions as a dangerous “third party” in the management-worker relationship — Riley MacLoed at Aftermath wrote an excellent excoriation of what he described as a “bullshit” perspective. The letters’ most interesting detail was a signature bearing only a first name: John. When asked, Powell and Vaine said everyone assumes this refers to WotC president John Hight — no other Johns exist in the tabletop publisher’s leadership structure. Without confirmation, union sympathizers have referred to the mysterious scold as simply “John Wizards”, “John Hasbro”, or “John WotC”.
Powell previously worked with Hight at Blizzard, where both were part of the World of Warcraft team. According to them, Hight was then much more sympathetic to collective action amongst developers and workers, even helping teams who pushed for what would eventually become the ABK Workers Alliance. Powell and Vaine claim Hight was present at an initial meeting with Arena workers held on the week UWOTC went public and joined the chorus of other managers in immediately undercutting the union’s demands.
Rascal reached out to Wizards of the Coast and Hasbro for comment but did not receive a reply.
The workers said that, while initially “caught flat-footed,” management spent that first meeting walking back assertions regarding return-to-office mandates that would force Arena workers to uproot their lives to relocate to Renton, Washington. Leaders consistently flooded internal work chat urging Arena staff to consider the drawbacks to unionizing, and all workers reportedly receive two emails per day filled with similar appeals. “We joke that the emails will continue until morale improves,” Vaine said.
The first email warned that union representatives might show up to people’s homes to evangelize, which Powell and Vaine denied ever being a plan. Instead, the two remarked at the irony of receiving letters one week later: “[it] felt like an invasion of privacy — they’ve already sent us the emails.” Emails reportedly came from a new address, “arenacommunications”, and eventually adopted a Q&A format with inquiries ostensibly submitted by staff members. Vaine and Powell said these questions were contrived and obvious setups for spouting more anti-union rhetoric, while another clarified that the answers were crafted by “a combination of Arena leadership, WotC leadership, and Fisher Phillips lawyers,” referencing a union avoidance firm hired by Hasbro and WotC.
Rascal asked to review emails and messages sent by WotC leadership, but the union refused to supply them, citing non-disclosure agreements and erring on the side of caution. Both pointed at the 30 union-supporting members fired from Rockstar for allegedly sharing confidential information, which prompted rebukes and legal action from the Independent Workers’ Union of Great Britain (IWGB).
For two weeks, arena folks have been getting *daily* anti-union emails from the company fearmongering about how scary unions are. Now, they're sending letters to our homes. The union isn't a third party, WE ARE THE UNION. This doesn't scare me. I am voting YES for #uwotc-cwa! #wotcstaff
— Xib (They/Them) IS UNIONIZING!!! 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️ (@xib.bsky.social) May 21, 2026 at 8:44 PM
[image or embed]
During the May 28 meeting, leadership reportedly told workers that a union would force the company to start tracking their work hours in order to avoid crunch conditions — one of the union’s key issues. Powell said one manager told him, “Isn’t it super scary that we would be looking at your time? That’s not a world I want to live in.” Vaine clarified that such a reality would only happen if WotC and the union agree to it — and that under the current model such decision making power rests wholly in the hands of their employer.
“It was exceptionally hard listening to someone in our leadership trying to guilt us, saying we’re sowing dissension in the ranks… that we’re making them unable to work on these policies. ‘I promise you, behind closed doors, I’ve been working on it,’” Powell said of past promises from WotC leadership. “You’ve told us for a year or more there’s nothing we can do. We’ve been told directly by HR that if we don’t like it, we should seek a job elsewhere. We don’t want to. We want to work here. We love this game, this company, and our people. We just want better working conditions.”
Workers aren’t the only ones facing increased pressure and propaganda from WotC’s anti-union stance. According to Vaine, Arena management and direct supervisors are pulled daily into “forced training meetings” about the union, which are led by Fisher Phillips lawyers and either Hasbro or WotC management. “We think they are being blasted every day with anti-union propaganda,” they said, claiming its fractured previously healthy relationships and turned colleagues into ideological enemies. The National Labor Relations Act (enforced by the NLRB) chiefly outlines protections for workers, not managers, so Vaine and Powell retained sympathy for those caught in an impossible situation. They said none of them had ever been part of a union and are facing management’s tactics without any recourse.
United Wizards of the Coast-CWA’s voting period begins on June 2 and will extend across at least two weeks to allow for remote voting (a detail workers say was curiously omitted from WotC’s letters). WotC is contesting union eligibility of certain roles, along with critical staff “who can keep the lights on”, said Vaine, perhaps indicating that the publisher remains frightened of a staff-wide strike. Powell and Vaine noted that the union is not calling for a strike and has no plans for such actions at the present time and will “fight Tooth and Nail” to keep everyone eligible.
The union is also not calling for a boycott, stressing that calls for such are neither protected speech under the NLRB nor something they want to ask of players and supporters. Instead, they urged the public to sign an open letter to management and voice their support online (“be kind to social media and customer support folks, please,” said Vaine).
Powell shared a petition to influential advocates: “If you’re a shareholder who’s pro-union, we would love to hear from you in meetings. I unabashedly think unions are a win for you, I promise,” they said. “And Brennan Lee Mulligan, if you want to give us a shoutout, I’d love that.”
