Ken St. Andre, creator of Tunnels & Trolls, has passed away

The designer of the second tabletop RPG left behind a decades-spanning legacy.

An image of Ken St. Andre imposed on the 5.5 edition of Tunnels & Trolls.
Image credit: Flying Buffalo Inc. / Photo source: Kickstarter

Ken St. Andre, the creator of Tunnels & Trolls, died on Sunday, November 15 at the age of 79. The announcement was made by designer and collaborator Steven Crompton on Kickstarter, who worked with St. Andre on tabletop RPG campaign, City State of the Immortal Goddesses. “He had been fighting cancer for over ten years and then his heart began to cause him troubles,” said Crompton on Kickstarter. “His wife Rocio and brother Brian were there at his side, helping him and managing the situation heroically, and special love should go to them for all the care they provided to Ken at his difficult time. Ken faced it bravely and tried to stay positive. I visited him a week before he passed and we shared memories, a few chuckles and he gave me some life advice, which I shall follow diligently.”

Tunnels & Trolls is widely regarded as the second tabletop RPG ever published, although St. Andre himself begged to differ; in a Facebook post made during his birthday just a few months ago in April, he referred to his game as the first RPG. “You might think that was Dungeons & Dragons, but Dungeons & Dragons was created as a miniatures war game simulation,” he wrote. “My game was intended from the beginning to be pure role-playing — no miniatures. You had to use your imagination when playing Tunnels & Trolls.” 

The first edition of Tunnels & Trolls, which was self-published by St. Andre. Source: TV Tropes

Self-published in April 1975, Tunnels & Trolls was crafted in response to D&D’s use of miniatures and polyhedral dice, which was particularly tough to purchase at that time. He also found the D&D system too complex and sought to create Tunnels & Trolls as a more approachable and easy to play alternative. While it didn’t receive the kind of mainstream popularity D&D enjoyed, Tunnels & Trolls did become the latter’s first serious competitor when the second edition was published by Flying Buffalo Inc. in June 1975. It also garnered a cult following in the decades to come, with fans affectionately referring to St. Andre as the “Trollgodfather.”

What’s distinctive about Tunnels & Trolls beyond its sense of whimsy and irreverence, which was refreshing in an era where many wargames and RPGs the likes of D&D had a more somber, even humorless facade. Take, for instance, the name of spells in Tunnels & Trolls, such as Hidey Hole, Take That, You Fiend, Little Feets…, and Oh-Go-Away.  Most recently, a reimagining of Tunnels & Trolls materialized in the form of Tunnels & Trolls: A New Age by Rebellion Unplugged. It’s a project that St. Andre wasn’t directly involved with, as he was working on an updated edition of Monsters! Monsters! at that time.

Tunnels & Trolls wasn’t the only RPG St. Andre designed. He subsequently released the sci-fi RPG Starfaring in 1976, as well as co-designed Stormbringer for Chaosium with Steven Perrin. “It’s a pitch-perfect old-school product with its demons bound into armor and weapons, its massively powerful sorcerers, and its lethal play,” wrote author and RPG historian Shannon Appelcline in a tribute post on St. Andre. “Many people point toward OD&D or Basic D&D as the old-school grail, Stormbringer is right up there, especially with its focus on the sword-and-sorcery genre.” In 1988, he became a writer and designer for the CRPG Wasteland, with its mechanics partly based on Tunnels & Troll’s system — that game eventually becoming the spiritual predecessor ro the first Fallout game. St. Andre was inducted into the Academy of Adventure Gaming Arts & Design’s Hall of Fame in June 2018.

Credit: Chaosium

Paying tribute to St. Andre on his site, author and designer Scott Malthouse, who worked on Tunnels & Trolls: A New Age, wrote that St. Andre was a vital part of RPG history. “I’ve known Ken for many years after coming to Trollhalla in the mid-to-late 2000s,” he wrote. “He was a complex individual, as we all are, at once gregarious and curmudgeonly – sometimes to the point of acidity. But there was never any doubt that his love for his games were transcendent, as was his fondness for the community that had foamed up around its rocky crags. It became a cottage industry of amateur zines, awful and splendid, where the same names would pop up across publications, often in their trollish pen-names (mine was Werrrdna).” Notable designer Matt Forbeck also said on Bluesky, “Despite his long standing in the industry, he never lost his sense of whimsy or fun, and I'll miss seeing him.”

St. Andre is survived by his wife, María del Rocío Ulloa López, his brother Brian, and two children, Jillian and James.